Wednesday, April 2, 2014

Fiberglass Vs. Stainless Steel Electrical Enclosures

Enclosure Material Considerations Fiberglass Vs. Stainless 

Additional Knowledge of Enclosure Materials Result in Long-term Reliability & Reduction of Cost for Controls
Environmental corrosion combined with the damage from impact will affect an enclosure’s ability to properly protect the controls and can cause a multitude of problems. Problems could include catastrophic and dangerous system collapses, production downtime, and injury to persons, increased maintenance costs and losses in customers. This is why it has become critical for Specifiers to become more knowledgeable about enclosure materials to prevent these complications.
Even though it should be simple enough to make a decision on the best enclosure material for the application, it can become overwhelming. The reason---- all of the enclosure materials available today, will meet the needs for most applications--- up to a point.  Nonetheless, one material will be superior when looking for long-term reliability and cost reduction.
Most control housings are typically made up of metals, thermoplastics, or composite materials. Below is a brief overview of the three main types of enclosure materials describing how they perform relative to preventing corrosion and impact resistance.  The information included here will make it easier going forward to make the right enclosure material selection.
Material Overview – Metals
Metals such as gold, platinum and palladium typically do not corrode. These metals are rarely used for control housing due to their high cost. Most other metals will corrode at different rates depending on a variety of factors including the type of metal and the environment.
Many Specifiers for enclosures select painted carbon steel for outdoor applications based on its low initial cost. Even though painted carbon steel enclosures can be a viable option and survive in many environments Specifiers need to be aware these enclosures can still fail if they are placed in areas where the enclosure is exposed to a more corrosive environment.  When the adhesion of paint to the carbon steel becomes compromised, the steel can rust.
This potential for failure of painted carbon steel enclosures causes many Specifiers to select stainless steel instead. Stainless steel enclosures are chosen because they are historically known to be corrosion resistant. Stainless steel is unique because the material contains about 10-1/2% chromium. Chromium, when in contact with oxygen, forms a natural barrier or film. This film protects the stainless steel from corrosion allowing it to survive in harsh environments for many years without incident. Once again, Specifiers need to be aware there are cases where the stainless steel film can become compromised.

stainless steel corrosion electrical enclosure box
In the photo above a stainless steel enclosure has a large area where the film has peeled away and the steel underneath has begun to rust. This rust spot will continue to grow and could eventually leave the controls inside unprotected.

Impact Strength of Metals
Many Specifiers choose metal enclosures based on their reputation for strength.
- Strength measures the resistance of a material to failure.
- Material toughness is its ability to withstand sudden impacts.
- Increasing strength, tensile or compression, usually decreases toughness and vice versa.
What Specifiers may not know is even though stainless steels have high strength, they exhibit low toughness allowing them to dent easily. When the stainless steel enclosure becomes dented the integrity of the box is jeopardized because it will not have a flush seal.
If an enclosure is not flush creates a situation where the seal loses its capability to be air and water tight. In addition, there exists the possibility for compromised security as the controls become easy to access.
Please remember, even though stainless steel is strong, its lack of toughness allows it to be damaged easily.


stainless steel dents broken golf course ding sprinkler
Above is an enclosure with visible damage from impact

Enclosures with Visible Damage from Impact

The first example (pictured above) is a stainless steel enclosure placed on a golf course in Orlando, Florida. The enclosure has been dented by the impact of stray golf balls. This repeated activity will eventually encumber the enclosure door and will expose the controls, costing the business more time and money to replace it.
The second example is a stainless steel enclosure with visible signs of impact in Westlake, Ohio. It is currently used to house traffic light controls at a busy intersection. The enclosure had been hit, with what appeared to be a baseball bat, causing it to open. This presents the owners with the potential problem of exposing young students, walking to school along this route, to the high voltage controls inside. An unimaginable event no owner or engineer would ever wish to deal with during a career.

stainless steel dents vandalize hit compromised electrical enclosure box high voltage


Materials Overview - Plastics

Thermoplastics—such as polycarbonate, polyester, ABS and PVC—offer a degree of corrosion protection beyond painted carbon and stainless steel. The challenge for use of thermoplastics in some applications is thermoplastics are more susceptible to UV exposure and weathering degradation over time. Certain stabilizers are now added to extend the life of the thermoplastic enclosure, but ultimately the nature of the thermoplastics will yield to extended weathering.
Composite Fiberglass is not susceptible to rust or other forms of oxidation. Composite Fiberglass enclosures also offer excellent chemical resistance to halogens (Chlorine, Fluorine). Similar to thermoplastics, composite fiberglass materials can be susceptible to exposure from the damaging effects of UV rays. Damage from UV exposure on composite materials is often call “fiber blooming”.
Today there are other options for fiberglass materials. There is a company that has found a way to combat the issue of “fiber blooming”. Stahlin Non-Metallic Enclosures developed SolarGuard® over 10 years ago.  SolarGuard® is a patented sheet molding compound formulation provides superior molded-in UV resistance. In extensive comparison testing, SolarGuard® outperformed other available SMC formulations by as much as 60% in its ability to retain gloss and color after exposure to concentrated UV light. SolarGuard® is also able to reduce the effects of UV degradation such as surface roughening and “fiber blooming”.

stahlin abita beer fiberglass electrical enclosure box
This is a Stahlin Non-Metallic enclosure with SolarGuard® molded into the material. It is currently located outside the Abita Brewing plant near New Orleans, Louisiana. The enclosure has had many years of constant exposure to harsh UV rays, extreme heat and humidity without any changes to the visual appearance thanks to the protection from SolarGuard®.

Thermoplastic and Composite Impact Resistance

Thermoplastics and thermosets (composites) exhibit average strength and a high level of toughness. This means they can withstand sudden impact and maintain their shape. A video of a metal crescent wrench hitting a fiberglass enclosure can be viewed at this link: http://youtu.be/WNleGNtJGD0
In the video you can see the impact from the wrench on the enclosure did not cause a dent, providing evidence of a composite enclosure’s durability out in the field where it could be subject to impact through vandalism.  Non-metallic materials are the better option when the application is located in an environment where impact damage is possible.
Summary
Each of these three enclosure materials---- metal, thermoplastics and composites materials will protect the controls in a variety of applications. It is important to know the environment and the application where the enclosure will be used because there are documented cases where the material selected for the application did not provide sufficient protection for the controls.   Using this information along with the material knowledge presented here, engineers can specify the best material for the project—guaranteeing long-term reliability and reduce overall cost for the controls.
References:
http://www.estainlesssteel.com/corrosion.shtml
http://events.nace.org/library/corrosion/Corrosion-History/Lessons.asp
stahlin stainless vs fiberglass.png

2 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete